SERP

Eyeliner pencils combine precision with smudge resistance, making them a favorite among makeup enthusiasts. Our carefully selected collection features a variety of formulas, from matte to metallic finishes, to help you find the perfect shade and texture for your look.

As an Amazon Associate, we receive compensation through qualifying purchases at no cost to you.

Reviews

Define Collection Needlepoint Eyeliner

This long-wearing eyeliner has earned a solid reputation among users for its precise application and staying power. The thin, marker-like tip makes it surprisingly simple to create both subtle and dramatic looks, while the formula glides on smoothly without the common issues of skipping or smudging. While a few users have noted minor flaking issues, most find it delivers beautiful results that last all day.

Chanel Le Crayon Khol Intense Eye Pencil

The Chanel Le Crayon Khol Intense Eye Pencil gives you the precision of a pencil with the blendable payoff of a kohl crayon. The smooth, latex-infused tip allows for easy, controlled application that's comfortable on your skin throughout the day. Available in a range of soft shades from cool brown to green, you'll find a color that matches your eye color perfectly. The creamy formula provides instant definition without the stiffness of traditional eyeliners, making it a versatile addition to your makeup routine.

IMAN Perfect Eye Pencil

This eyeshadow pencil combines rich pigmentation with a smooth, blendable formula that works equally well for defining eyes or highlighting brows. While some users appreciate its longevity, others note the color can be quite dark, so patch testing is recommended. The built-in sharpener makes touch-ups a breeze.

L.A. Girl Ultimate Intense Stay Eyeliner

A decent performer in the world of affordable eyeliners, this mechanical pencil packs a punch with its creamy formula that actually lives up to its promise of comfort during application - something many reviewers praised. While the charcoal shade does possess a subtle shimmer that might catch some by surprise, users consistently praise its intense blackness and staying power throughout the day.

Maybelline New York Lasting Drama Matte Eyeliner

This jet-black eyeliner delivers intense color with a creamy matte finish that lasts for hours without smudging or fading. The long-wearing formula is perfect for defining bold eyes, while the smooth application makes it a breeze to use. It works great for both waterline and lid application, though some may find the tip needs regular sharpening for the best results.

Natasha Moor Cosmetics Kohl Me Fantastick Eyeliner Pencil

This ultra-black eyeliner delivers flawless lines that resist smudging and water. The vegan formula is free from harsh chemicals, making it a great option for those who prefer clean cosmetics. While it needs a bit of sharpening attention, the result is a long-wearing eyeliner that helps you achieve precise cat-eye looks.

12 Color Eyeliner Pencil Set

These pencils come with lids to protect their retractable leads, which twist up for easy application without the need for sharpening. The dozen pure color options include everything from classic black to bold blue, making it simple to achieve anything from a subtle base to dramatic smoky eyes. The warmable, pigmented formula makes it a breeze to get just the right look, while the dual-purpose design lets you use them for both eyeliner and brow filling.

Jordana Draw The Line Eyeliner Pencil

This creamy eyeliner pencil applies smoothly and lasts for hours without smudging or bleeding. The built-in sharpener makes touch-ups easy, and its waterproof formula performs well in the waterline. It's cruelty-free and available in eight shades, including a popular gray that users love for both eyeliner and browfiller. The long-lasting precision makes it a favorite despite some minor drawbacks mentioned in the reviews.

Maybelline Hyper Easy No-Slip Pencil Eyeliner

This gel eyeliner features a 1.5mm micro tip and creamy formula for precise application, while argan oil provides nourishment. The hexagonal grip ensures stability, making it easier to achieve perfect lines. Available in three skin-flattering shades, the waterproof formula works well for both beginners and experienced users.

Palladio Eye Liner, Herbal, Pure Black 01

This waterproof eyeliner glides on smoothly without sharpening, making application simple and mess-free. The pure black formula gives you a bold look with rich color intensity, while the herbal-based pigment ensures smooth application that lasts all day – even through pool parties and sweaty workouts. The nine shade palette lets you switch between neutral and dramatic looks, with long-lasting results that only need touching up in the afternoon.

City Color Photo Chic Eyeliner Pencil

This little eyeliner pencil packs a big punch of color in its 0.2 fl oz container. The assortment of 12 shades will help you mix up your makeup looks, from subtle everyday wear to bold statements. The matte finish and long-wearing formula make it a practical choice that's resistant to smudging or fading throughout the day. While some users report occasional drying issues midway through the pencil, the sharp application and vibrant color payoff make it a solid pick for both daily wear and special occasions.

Yves Rocher Kohl Pencil

The Yves Rocher Kohl Pencil combines a creamy texture with natural ingredients for a precise eye-enhancing effect. Available in five shades, this vegan-friendly liner glides on smoothly and lasts all day, with a formula tested for sensitivity. Cornflower extract helps care for delicate eye areas while the simple application makes it perfect for both everyday use and creating dramatic looks.

Tintaline Waterproof Eye Liner Pencil

This versatile waterproof eyeliner delivers rich, lasting color with a silky-smooth application. The professional-grade formula glides on evenly, allowing for precise lines that stand up to moisture without smudging or running. While some users have noted occasional issues with the pencil's stability, particularly when exposed to heat, the majority rave about its staying power and overall quality.

Kate Super Sharp Black Eyeliner Pencil

This black eyeliner pencil delivers precise, smudge-proof definition with its 1.3mm core. Users appreciate its stable application and good color payoff, though some wish the core were slightly thicker for easier wielding. The almond-shaped design prevents breakage while maintaining fine tip control.

Chifure Eyeliner Pencil

The chifure pencil eyeliner glides on smoothly with a soft touch, making it a breeze to create crisp, natural-looking lines. At just the right thickness for precise application, it's a popular choice among reviewers who appreciate its consistent performance and affordable price point. While some users report occasional smudging, particularly on upper eyelids, the easy-sharpening pencil and natural finish make it a reliable everyday option for defined eyes.

Eyeko Limitless Long-Wear Pencil Eyeliner

These long-wearing eye pencils pack surprisingly bold color in a soft, creamy formula that glides seamlessly onto the lash line or water line. With five standout shades—magnetic jet black, luxe royal blue, warm plum purple, cool brown, and neutral cream—the Eyeko Limitless liners excel at defining eyes without the tug or tug-of-war sharpening sessions that plague some waterproof formulas. While a few users struggle with the stiff wood casing, most praise the smudge-proof pigment that lasts all day without fading or transfer.

Makeup by Mario Master Pigment Pro Eyeliner

This eyeliner delivers intense color with surprisingly smooth application, thanks to its unique gel-like formula that glides on effortlessly. The built-in brush allows for easy blending and smudging, while the sharpener keeps the pencil tip pristine between uses. Whether you're creating a precise wing or a smudged look, this versatile liner delivers long-wearing pigmentation without the transfer issues that can plague pencil products.

19PC La Girl Gel Glide Eyeliner Pencil Set

The 19-piece La Girl gel glide eyeliner pencil set lets you try out 19 different shades of highly pigmented eyeliner. Each pencil glides on smoothly and can be sharpened for precise lines. The set includes the brand's DreamyVibes collection and their popular Kajal auto liner.

Essence Kajal Pencil in Fuchsia 24

This kajal pencil delivers rich color with smooth application, though some noted it excels better for upper lash lines than waterlines. The formula's blend of pigmentation and glide earned praise despite minor drawbacks like splintering tips and moderate fade over time. With lasting appeal in various shades, it stands out for its quality-to-price ratio among budget-friendly options.

Shany Slim Liner Eye Pencil: Vicious Formula

From warm purples to matte neutrals, these versatile eyeliner and lip pencils offer a creamy payoff with smooth application. At 5.75 inches long, the multi-purpose pencils include both metallic and matte finishes in a range of shades. While some find them a bit stiff, many customers appreciate their staying power and creamy formula, making them a favorite for both makeup beginners and pros.

KVD Beauty Mini Tattoo Pencil Liner 0.35g Trooper Black

The KVD Beauty Mini Tattoo Pencil Liner delivers long-wearing, vivid black color perfect for precision cat eyes and waterline application. At just 0.35g, this travel-friendly pencil packs a powerful punch—each swipe is intensely pigmented yet easy to control with a brush. While some users find it works best with setting powder to prevent smudging, the creamy formula creates flawless, lasting eyes that resist smudging from sweat and tears.

L.A. Colors Eyeliner Pencil in Violet

This violet eyeliner pencil brings a deep, rich purple to your makeup routine. It glides on smoothly and packs a pigmented punch, making it perfect for defining and accentuating your eyes. The single-sharpener design keeps your pencil in top condition, though the color payoff might take some practice to master.

L.A Colors Black Eyeliner Pencil

The L. A. Colors eyeliner pencil delivers a dramatic, long-lasting alternative to liquid liners while maintaining surprisingly easy application. Its smooth formula glides on effortlessly and stays put throughout the day, making it a practical choice for both everyday wear and special occasions. The built-in sharpener ensures your pencil always maintains a perfect point for precise lining, while a generous color payoff allows each pencil to last through multiple applications.

Avon Glimmersticks Eye Liner, Blackest Black (3-pack)

These long-wearing eye liners make dramatic looks simple with their creamy formula that glides on smoothly. Available in a 3-pack featuring the blackest black color that delivers intense depth without harshness. The precision applicator lets you create both subtle everyday looks and bold evening glamour with lasting results.

Merle Norman Soft Touch Eye Pencil

This ultra-creamy double-ended pencil shapes and defines eyes with smooth-gliding color that last for hours. Whether you're creating a smoky look or prepping your lids for powder, these blend-able formulas deliver exactly what you need for your next eye makeup masterpiece.

L.A. Colors Auto Eyeliner

The L. A. Colors black eyeliner pencil brings intense color to your eyes with its smooth twist-up design. It glides on evenly and lasts all day without smudging, though some users find it needs retouching every few hours. Enriched with shea butter, the formula makes application a breeze, eliminating the need for sharpening.

L.A. Girl Kajal Auto Eyeliner (Super Black)

The creamy formula of this kajal eyeliner glides smoothly on both upper and lower lash lines, making it ideal for creating intense smoky eyes or precise winged looks. Its long-lasting, smudge-proof formula keeps your linework perfect for hours, while the convenient twist-up design and built-in sharpener make application a breeze. The intense black color payoff is praised by users for its boldness and richness, with many noting its superior performance compared to other budget-friendly eyeliners in their collection.

La Girl Shockwave Neon Eyeliner

The La Girl Shockwave Neon Eyeliner delivers brilliantly pigmented, long-wearing color that really packs a punch. It applies smoothly with a creamy texture that doesn't tug at your skin, and the bold neon shades are perfect for adding serious spark to your look. While some users have noted minor sharpening issues, the formula's water-resistant properties and 16-hour wear time make it a reliable choice for both everyday wear and special occasions.

Nyx Professional Makeup Jumbo Eye Pencil

This versatile eye pencil glides on smoothly with a creamy formula that works wonders both as an eyeliner and eyeshadow primer. The long-lasting color payoff makes it a reliable choice for defining eyes or creating soft, blended looks. While some may struggle to sharpen due to the plastic casing, the pigmented formula and smooth application make it worth the minor hassle for achieving professional-grade eye makeup.

K7L Brown Eyeliner Pencil

This brown eyeliner pencil is precision-engineered for intense, crease-free definition. The ultra-fine tip allows for meticulous dot placement above the lash line, while the long-wearing formula keeps your look perfect through all-day activities. The waterproof formulation means your eyeliner stays put during unexpected rain showers or intense workout sessions, giving you reliable performance for every occasion.

Kylie Cosmetics Gel Eyeliner Pencil

From bold smoky eyes to precise winged liners, this gel pencil delivers intense color that lasts all day without smudging. The creamy formula applies smoothly with just one stroke, making it perfect for both beginners and experienced makeup artists. With a variety of shades ranging from sultry blacks to radiant shimmers, you'll find the perfect liner to match any look.

Fenty Beauty Flypencil Eyeliner

This ultra-smooth eyeliner glides on with a creamy precision, offering a range of finishes from matte to metallic. The water-resistant formula delivers rich color without the need to reapply, while the twist-up design allows for easy control. With shades that transition beautifully from hand to lid, it's a versatile addition to any makeup routine—although some users may find the formula too dry for their liking.

Essence Kajal Pencil

This highly-rated kajal pencil delivers intense color with effortless application, though some customers have noted minor quality issues with the wooden tip. The heavily pigmented formula creates a dramatic look that lasting for hours, while the soft consistency makes it easy to define your eyes. Available in various shades, it's a versatile addition to any makeup collection, requiring only simple maintenance for consistent results.

Pat McGrath Labs Permagel Ultra Glide Eye Pencil

With a blendable gel formula that's as smooth as a pencil, these waterproof eyeliner essentials deliver intense pigmentation while remaining surprisingly easy to work with. Choose from an impressive array of shades, from classic blacks and browns to striking blue metallic options, each delivering rich coverage that lasts all day without smudging. The soft, silicone-infused tips apply effortlessly, allowing you to create precise lines or smudge for a smokey effect – once it sets, it's locked in place for hours.

Wowcombo Ultimate Waterproof Eyeliner

This eyeliner makes defined eyes with ease, giving you that perfect line every time. The built-in sharpener makes it a breeze to use, and thanks to its smudge-proof formula, your makeup stays put all day long – perfect for those long days at work or weekend getaways. The professional-grade pigmentation means you're getting a quality product that delivers on its promises.

IL Makiage Long-Wear Eye Pencil

This creamy eye pencil applies smoothly with intense color payoff. The long-wear formula prevents smudging and fading throughout the day. With nourishing ingredients for the delicate eye area, it provides lasting wear without tug or pull.

Victoria Beckham Satin Kajal Liner in Bronze

This richly pigmented kajal liner delivers intense color with a single stroke, gliding smoothly onto the lash line. The creamy formula applies effortlessly and can be easily blended for everyday wear or built up for dramatic looks. Infused with Vitamin E and pro-vitamin B5, it provides lasting wear without creasing or flaking.

Chanel Stylo Yeux Waterproof Long-Lasting Eyeliner

The sleek, retractable design makes this waterproof eyeliner a cinch to apply – just like sharpening a regular pencil! It's incredibly pigmented, giving you intense definition that lasts all day without smudging or running. The Italian craftsmanship shows in every detail, from the smooth glide to the foolproof formula that works perfectly on sensitive eyes.

Lakmé Eyeconic Kajal

The Lakmé Eyeconic Kajal Deep Black combines a creamy texture with long-lasting smudge-proof formula. At just 0.35g, the compact pencil is perfect for touch-ups on-the-go, while its convenient twist-up design makes application quick and easy. The formula, enriched with camphor and almond oil, provides intense black color without irritation, making it a practical choice for everyday wear or bold makeup looks.

R.E.M. Beauty at The Borderline Kohl Eyeliner Pencil

This long-wearing eyeliner has earned a strong following for its intense pigmentation and smooth application – once you get the hang of it. The formula's praised for its creamy texture that glides on effortlessly once you master the technique, making it a reliable option for both everyday wear and bold looks. While some struggle with the stiff pencil at first, many users report dramatic improvements in application quality after the initial break-in period.

L.A Colors Electric Blue Eyeliner Pencil

The L. A. Colors Eyeliner Pencil features a smooth formula that glides on easily and sets quickly for long-lasting wear. The electric blue shade works beautifully on fair complexions and allows for precise application or a softer smoky look with the built-in smudger. While some users have noted the color intensity can vary, the overall quality and pricing make it a solid choice for defining and accentuating eyes.

italia 1003 Ultra Fine Eyeliner

These creamy eyeliner pencils deliver intense, matte color that glides on smoothly and sets to a lasting finish. The ultra-fine tip makes it easy to create precise lines that stay put throughout the day, whether you're wearing them just on the waterline to open up your eyes or defining your entire lash line. Users praise the pigmentation and creamy texture that prevents smudging while providing great coverage.

BONNIESTORE 20 Color Eye Liner Pencil Set

This versatile 20-color eyeliner set combines precision and pigmentation for lasting makeup results suitable for daily wear and special occasions. The 3-in-1 pencils function as eyeliner, eyeshadow, and highlighter, perfect for compact makeup storage. The waterproof and sweat-proof formula delivers smooth application throughout the day.

12pcs Erinde White Eyeliner Pencils

The 12-pc Erinde white eyeliner set features soft, smudge-proof pigmentation in a convenient travel-friendly design. The mild formula glides on smoothly without irritation, making it perfect for sensitive skin types. Each pencil is housed in a compact package that's ideal for touch-ups on the go.

e.l.f. Satin Eyeliner Pencil in Coffee

With its rich, smudge-proof pigment and convenient built-in sharpener, the e. l. f. Satin Eyeliner Pencil makes achieving a precise wing or natural liner look a breeze. The creamy formula glides smoothly onto the lash line, creating a beautiful satin finish that lasts all day without feathering or bleeding. The vegan and cruelty-free formula makes it a guilt-free choice for everyday wear.

Nyx Professional Jumbo Eyeliner Pencil

These smooth, creamy eyeliner pencils glide on effortlessly, their mineral oil and powder blend making them perfect for professional-looking cat eyes without the tug or pull. The pencils sharpen easily to a point and come in a choice of 24 shades, from classic black and brown to bold colors like electric blue and shimmering gold. While some users have noted that the formula can dry out over time, the creamy texture and blend of aloe vera and vitamin E make it a popular choice for both beginners and makeup artists.

NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil

This creamy eye pencil glides on smoothly with a natural matte finish, thanks to its blend of mineral oils and waxes. The highly pigmented formula works double-duty as both eyeliner and eyeshadow, available in 19 vivid shades. Whether you're creating a subtle wash of color or a dramatic winged look, these comfortable-to-wear pencils deliver lasting intensity without creasing.

NYX Professional Makeup Retractable Eyeliner

These creamy eyeliners twist into place for foolproof application, with rich pigmentation that lasts all day without smudging. The long-wearing formula makes them perfect for both daily wear and special occasions, while the soft texture glides on smoothly without tug or pull. Available in multiple shades for every makeup mood.

Bold Beautiful Cosmetics Smudge-Proof Eyeliner Pencil

This easy-to-use eyeliner pencil offers 24-hour, waterproof wear that's perfect for both daily use and special occasions. The smooth gel formula glides on evenly without irritation, even on sensitive eyes. The convenient mechanical pencil design makes it simple to control the line thickness while eliminating the need for sharpening.

L.A. Girl Ultimate Intense Stay Auto Eyeliner

This gel eyeliner glides on smoothly with a creamy texture that makes application a breeze, though some may find the softer formula requires a steady hand for fine lines. The highly pigmented formula delivers rich color with sharp definition while remaining water-resistant throughout the day. Users particularly love how it prevents smudging and fading, though a few note the mechanical pencil can be tricky to sharpen.

Buyer's Guide

Eyeliner pencils offer a blend of precision and darkness, making them a staple in many makeup routines. Understanding their features and applications can help you choose the right pencil for your style and needs.

Core Quality: Formula

The best eyeliner pencils feature a creamy, smudge-proof formula that glides on smoothly while maintaining sharp definition. These typically contain pigments like iron oxides or carbon black for intensity.

Rigidity: Lead Hardness

Eyeliner pencils range from hard to soft based on their lead hardness. Hard pencils create fine lines, ideal for beginners, while soft ones offer more flexibility for creating winged or cat eye looks.

Applicability: Wipeable Lead

A smudge-proof lead that wipes clean during application prevents product waste and allows for precise touch-ups. This feature is particularly useful for beginners who may struggle with consistent lines.

Comfort: Grip and Size

Handle design affects pencil grip, with most featuring slanted ends for better control. Compact sizes are convenient for travel, while larger ones provide more product for everyday use.

FAQ

What is an eyeliner pencil?

Eye liner pencils are solid cosmetics containing pigmented formula that can be applied directly to the eyelid to create defined lines. They're praised for their precision and ease of use, offering a balance between sharp lines and natural looks.

These pencils typically feature a small, angled tip that allows for careful application along the lash line, while some models include a built-in sharpener for maintaining a fine point.

What types of formulas are available?

Eye liner pencils come in various formulas, including water-based, gel, and cream formulations. Water-based pencils are popular for their blendability, while gel formulas offer intense color and wear. Cream pencils provide the most pigmentation and are ideal for creating bold looks.

Some pencils incorporate additional benefits like waterproofing, color-shifting properties, or nourishing ingredients, catering to specific skincare and makeup preferences.

How do I choose the right shade?

The most versatile shades are usually black and brown, as they match most eye colors and skin tones. Black works well with any eye color, while brown can enhance the natural hue of your eyes. Smoky grays and cool-toned browns suit blue and green eyes, while warm-toned browns complement hazel and brown eyes.

Consider the season and occasion when selecting a shade. Nudes and soft browns suit daytime wear, while dark blacks and rich browns are ideal for evening looks.

What tips should I use for application?

Start by drawing a light guide line with the pencil, then define the edges for a more precise look. Use a thin brush or cotton swab to soften the edges and blend the pencil into the skin for a seamless finish.

To extend the wear, set the liner with a translucent setting spray or a touch of setting powder. For smudging, use a damp brush or your finger to blend the edges, creating a soft, smoky effect.

How do I properly maintain an eyeliner pencil?

Always keep the pencil tip clean and store it in a protective case when not in use to prevent smudging and maintain its shape. If the tip becomes dull, gently sharpen it using the built-in sharpener or a dedicated sharpener.

Keep the pencil in a cool, dry place to prevent melting and maintain its shape. If the pencil becomes too soft, consider using it as a shadow or brow pencil for more intense color.

Can I use an eyeliner pencil if I have sensitive eyes?

Most eyeliner pencils are suitable for sensitive eyes, but look for formulas specifically labeled as hypoallergenic and fragrance-free. If you have allergies to certain ingredients, check the ingredient list before purchase.

If you experience irritation, discontinue use and consult a dermatologist. Switching to a formula with natural ingredients or a thicker consistency might help if you have sensitive skin.