Reel in the Catch - 10 Best Fly Fishing Reels for Expert Anglers

Welcome avid fly fishermen and enthusiasts to our roundup of the top fly fishing reels on the market. Discover the best reels for your next angling adventure, as we dive into their features, performance, and value for your coin. Gear up and let’s hit the water!

As an Amazon Affiliate™ we receive compensation through qualifying purchases at no cost to you.

Reviews

Hardy Marquis Saltwater Fly Reel

I recently had the pleasure of using the Hardy Marquis LWT Reel, and let me tell you, it didn’t disappoint. The reel is a true testament to Hardy’s mastery of craftsmanship, and it’s clear that every detail has been thoughtfully designed for functionality and beauty.

What stood out to me the most was the improved range of adjustment, which made it incredibly easy to fine-tune the drag to my liking. The updated yet classic styling was also a refreshing change, as it managed to blend modern technology with timeless design. And speaking of modern technology, the modified porting to reduce weight was a game-changer. It made the reel feel lightweight and agile without sacrificing its robustness.

However, there were a couple of areas where the Hardy Marquis LWT Reel could use some refinement. While the quick-change spool made it easy to switch between left- and right-handed operation, I found that I had to constantly readjust it to keep it in place. Additionally, although I appreciated the anodized aluminum and stainless steel components for durability, I couldn’t help but feel that the reel was a bit too expensive for its features.

Overall, the Hardy Marquis LWT Reel is a standout choice for anyone in the market for a high-quality saltwater fly reel. While it may not be perfect, its exceptional craftsmanship, sleek design, and user-friendly features make it hard to pass up.

Lamson Guru S Fly Reel - Blaze / 3+: Superior Fly Fishing Performance

The Lamson Guru S Fly Reel is a redesigned version of the classic Guru reels. The Guru II Series boasts improved weight and performance due to the enhanced spool machining technique that concentrates material where it’s needed. The new design is just as rugged as the previous ones, with the added bonus of being fully USA-machined. It’s lightweight, high-quality, and will balance any modern rod.

The reel has a conical drag system, suitable for fly fishing in both freshwater and saltwater environments. It features a large arbor with a 3.55 diameter, making it ideal for catching larger fish. The materials used include machined 6061 aluminium and stainless steel, providing durability and a sleek finish.

One of the most noticeable features of the Lamson Guru S Fly Reel is its large arbor, which helps to keep the line from tangling and ensures smooth retrieval. The material used for the arbor is stainless steel, which adds an extra layer of durability. The drag on this reel is adjustable and smooth, making it perfect for both beginners and experienced fly fishermen alike.

While the Lamson Guru S Fly Reel is an excellent choice for fly fishing enthusiasts, there are a few things to consider. For one, it may be a bit heavier than some other reels on the market. Additionally, the drag may be a bit tighter than what some users prefer, especially when using finer tippets. These are minor drawbacks, however, and shouldn’t deter serious fly fishermen from giving this reel a try.

Overall, the Lamson Guru S Fly Reel is a high-quality and beautifully designed reel that will enhance any fly fishing experience. Its enhanced spool machining technique makes it lighter and more durable, while its large arbor and smooth drag system ensure that every cast is a smooth and successful one.

Limitless Saltwater Fly Reel L/R Conversion

The Cheeky Limitless Fly Reel has become my go-to for both saltwater and freshwater fishing. The 475 model in particular caught my attention with its innovative GDS fully sealed drag system, offering a smooth and powerful drag without any worries of interference from salt, sand, or debris.

Its aerospace aluminum construction and multi-axis machining make it incredibly strong, while still maintaining a lightweight design. The integrated reel foot disperses torque throughout the frame, providing stability during even the toughest fights. The line capacity is outstanding, and the unbeatable arbor size ensures maximum retrieval rate.

The Limitless series, available in a variety of sizes from 2wt to 16wt, also offers easy left/right conversion. The 475 model I’ve been using is my favorite, but I’ve heard great things about the other sizes as well. Its durable build and eye-catching design have become favorites for many, including myself.

Despite being new to the fly fishing world, I’ve had no complaints and have already caught hundreds of fish using it. The Cheeky Limitless Fly Reel is truly a modern marvel, and I can’t help but be excited for the future models that may be released.

Hatch Custom Jolly Roger Iconic Fly Reel 2023

Introducing the Hatch 2023 Custom Iconic Fly Reel, featuring the distinctive Jolly Roger design. Crafted with precision and passion in Southern California, this reel boasts a stunning gold anodization and intricate engraving. Each purchase comes with a protective pouch and a convenient cap wrench.

However, do take note that this model is not compatible with previous spool designs. Ideal for fly fishing enthusiasts, this reel features a 4.125-inch diameter and supports line weights of 7-9, making it a reliable and stylish addition to your fishing gear.

3-Pack Lamson Liquid Fly Fishing Reels - Smoke Color

The Lamson Liquid Reel, a top-notch pressure die cast reel, promises exceptional value for money. A standout feature is the flawless integration of the same smooth and robust drag system found across all Lamson reels.

Available either as a single reel or a pack with an extra spool, this versatile option caters to a variety of fishing needs. The reel’s strong and smooth drag system, along with the precision crafted aluminum housing, ensures a seamless performance, while the large arbor design helps prevent line stacking.

Despite the occasional difficulties with shipping to certain locations, the positives far outweigh the negatives in the realm of this reel.

M Maximumcatch Tino Trout Fly Fishing Reel

The Maximumcatch Tino Fly Fishing Reel is a standout product in the market, engineered with both die-casting and machine-cutting technology. This large arbor trout fly reel, available in a 5/6 or 7/8 weight, is equipped with a cutting-edge Teflon disc and stainless steel drag system.

The one-way clutch bearing ensures smooth and immediate drag engagement. Its quick release spool can be easily switched from a left to right hand retrieve.

Combined with a 1-year warranty and ambidextrous handle, the Maximumcatch Tino is perfect for fly fishing enthusiasts seeking a high-quality, performance-driven reel.

Orvis Battenkill Fly Reel: Classic Click-and-Pawl Design for Freshwater Fishing

Imagine casting your line into the water, surrounded by the calm and soothing sounds of nature. As a seasoned fisherman, I was intrigued by the Orvis Battenkill Fly Reel. Known for its simple yet elegant design, this reel is made to be flawless in construction and work perfectly for nearly every freshwater fishing situation.

When I first used it, I was impressed by its minimalist approach. The Battenkill boasts a classically styled, yet technically enhanced, four-position click-and-pawl drag system that operates smoothly and in tandem with my hand during those exhilarating runs. The narrow spool design minimizes line stacking on my retrieve and a larger spool diameter allows for even higher line retrieval rates.

However, I did find that the adjustments made the reel more suitable for beginners rather than experts in the fishing world. Additionally, I wish the line could be attached to the reel during the purchasing process, as the packaging requires extra legwork.

Overall, the Orvis Battenkill Fly Reel is a durable and dependable choice - perfect for any fisherman ready to dive into the world of freshwater fishing. From its sleek design to its smooth operation, it truly does make all the difference when it comes to that perfect fishing experience.

Ross Animas 5/6 Matte Olive Saltwater Fly Reel

I recently took the Ross Animas 5/6 reel with me on a fishing trip to a nearby river. I was immediately impressed by its sleek matte olive finish, which made it stand out from the other reels I’ve used. The handle felt lightweight yet sturdy, and the spool design was a real eye-catcher.

One feature that I truly appreciated was the smooth drag system. It allowed me to easily control the line as I reeled in a large, hard-running rainbow trout. The reel’s performance was so impressive that I even received compliments from fellow anglers on the river.

However, one downside I encountered was the spool release. On a few occasions, it proved to be a bit of a hassle, especially when I needed to quickly change the line. Although it’s not a major issue, it’s worth considering for those looking for a reel with zero-maintenance performance.

Overall, the Ross Animas 5/6 reel has become a reliable addition to my fishing gear. Its modern design, lightweight yet sturdy construction, and smooth drag system make it a top choice for any fly fisherman seeking a high-quality, versatile reel.

Angler Dream Ex-Alc 7/8wt CNC Aluminum Fly Reels in Silver/Gunsmoke

I recently took a dip into the exciting world of fly fishing and decided to try out the Angler Dream Ex-alc Fly Reel. What struck me the moment I took it out of the box was its sleek, silver and gunsmoke finish. Its CNC-machined 6061-T6 aluminum alloy build made it feel sturdy and durable, perfect for fishing in various environments.

One of the first tasks I had to do was assemble the reel myself, and although it was a simple process, following the instructions to the T was key to ensure the smooth operation of the reel. The reel is designed for clearwater, and I was warned to inspect and clean it after use in saltwater to prevent corrosion. A bit of a downside, but understandable given the reel’s construction.

Using the fly reel felt like a dream come true. The 2+1 ball bearings and the 1:1 gear ratio provided a smooth, consistent drag. My favorite feature, however, was its quiet operation - no more noisy pulling or retrieving! The adjustable drag was also a nice touch, giving me the control I needed to handle fish of various sizes.

So, all in all, if you’re in the market for a high-quality fly fishing reel on a budget, look no further. The Angler Dream Ex-alc Fly Reel offers excellent performance and durability without breaking the bank. Just make sure to follow the care instructions for optimal performance.

White River Fly Shop Dogwood Canyon DGW34 - High-Performance Fly Fishing Reel

I recently gave the White River Fly Shop Dogwood Canyon Fly Reel (DGW34) a spin during my trout fishing adventures at the White River. This all-aluminum reel, with its sleek, modern design, instantly drew me in. I was impressed by how quick and easy it was to switch from right- to left-hand retrieve, making it a perfect companion for my fishing expedition.

On the water, the multi-disk drag system was a game-changer! It slowed down and turned hard-swimming hookups without any trouble. The large-arbor design also proved to be a winner, minimizing line memory and enabling super-fast line retrieval. Overall, the all-around performance of this fly reel was nothing short of spectacular!

While the reel handled even the toughest trout without a dent, the one downside I encountered was the paint scratching issue. But hey, a few scratches are a small price to pay for such an awesome reel that helps me reel in the big guys in no time!

Buyer’s Guide

Welcome to our comprehensive buyer’s guide for fly fishing reels. In this section, we’ll discuss the essential features to consider when purchasing a fly fishing reel, as well as providing general advice and tips for users. Keep in mind that we won’t recommend specific products or external resources, so you can focus on understanding the fundamentals of selecting the perfect reel for your needs.

Types of Fly Fishing Reels

Fly fishing reels come in three primary types: bamboo, aluminum, and carbon fiber. Each type has its own advantages and disadvantages. Bamboo reels are traditional and elegant, but they tend to be heavier and more expensive. Aluminum reels are lightweight, durable, and budget-friendly, making them popular for many anglers. Carbon fiber reels are the lightest and most expensive, offering high-performance features but also requiring proper care to ensure longevity.

Drag System

The drag system is a crucial component in fly fishing reels, as it helps control the line tension when fighting a fish. There are two primary drag systems: clicking and disc. Clicking drags provide a smooth start-up but tend to wear down over time. Disc drags offer a smoother and more consistent performance but are more expensive. Consider your budget and fishing preferences when choosing between clicking and disc drag systems.

Reel Size

Fly fishing reels come in various sizes, measured by the diameter of the spool. Smaller reels (6-7 inches) are ideal for smaller trout and lightweight flies, while larger reels (10-12 inches) are better suited for larger fish and heavier flies. Choose a reel size that best suits your fishing style and the types of fish you target.

Gear Ratio

Gear ratio refers to the number of times the spool rotates for every full turn of the handle. A higher gear ratio results in faster line retrieval but can cause the spool to overrun if not managed correctly. A lower gear ratio provides better control but may result in slower retrieval speeds. Consider your fishing preferences and the conditions you encounter when choosing a reel with the appropriate gear ratio.

FAQ

What are the most important features of a fly fishing reel?

The most important features of a fly fishing reel are its weight, handle, drag system, and materials. A lightweight reel is easy to cast and reduces fatigue. The handle should be comfortable and allow for a secure grip. The drag system is crucial for controlling the line, preventing breakages, and maintaining line control. Sturdy materials like anodized aluminum and stainless steel are preferred for durability and resistance to corrosion and wear.

Another important feature is the compatibility of the reel with fly lines and leaders, and the ability to retrieve line easily. Look for reels that can handle the weight and line diameter of the specific fishing conditions you plan to use them in, while maintaining smooth operation and strength during use.

How do I maintain my fly fishing reel?

Proper maintenance of your fly fishing reel is essential for its longevity and performance. First, clean the reel after every use, removing any dirt, sand, or debris that may have accumulated on the reel or line. You can use a brush, toothbrush, or small comb to gently remove these particles. Next, ensure that there is no corrosion or abrasion on the moving parts, and apply a lubricant like reel grease to maintain smooth operation. Be sure to check and tighten any loose parts, and replace worn components as needed. Regular maintenance will preserve the reel’s performance and life.

Also, consider investing in a protective case or covering to guard against accidental damage and protect the reel when not in use. By following these maintenance tips, you can extend the life and performance of your fly fishing reel and get the most out of your investment. Remember to read the manufacturer’s guide for specific recommendations and maintenance instructions.

What are the different types of drag systems in fly fishing reels?

Fly fishing reels typically feature two types of drag systems: Click-and-Pull and Disk drag. Click-and-Pull reels have a simple, adjustable drag system that increases or decreases tension by turning a knob or lever. This type of drag is straightforward, easy to use, and often reliable, but it may not offer the fine-tuning or consistent performance found in disk drag systems.

Disk drag reels use friction-generating discs and pads to control the line. This drag system generally offers smoother operation, more consistent tension, and greater control, especially when fighting large or wary fish. However, disk drag systems can be more complex and may require more frequent adjustments to maintain optimal performance. Both types of drag systems have their advantages and disadvantages, and the choice between them may depend on your personal preference, fishing experience, and specific needs.

Which materials are best for crafting fly fishing reels?

Fly fishing reels are typically made from anodized aluminum or stainless steel, both of which offer excellent durability and resistance to corrosion and wear. These materials are lightweight but also strong enough to handle the demands of fly fishing. Stainless steel is a more expensive option, as it requires higher levels of manufacturing expertise and craftsmanship. Anodized aluminum is more common and affordable, but it may not be as resistant to wear and tear as stainless steel.

The choice between these two materials will mainly come down to personal preference, budget, and desired performance. Look for reels that are well-designed and feature high-quality components, regardless of the material used. The best reel for you will depend on your personal style, budget, and intended use.

Are there any factors to consider when choosing the size of a fly fishing reel?

Yes, there are several factors to consider when selecting the size of a fly fishing reel. The size of the reel will have an impact on its weight, line capacity, and ease of use. First, consider the types and sizes of fish you plan to target, as this will influence the reel’s line capacity. For instance, larger fish typically require heavier lines, which in turn demand a sturdier reel.

Second, the overall size, weight, and balance of the reel will affect your comfort and the ease of casting. A reel that is too large or heavy may be tiring to use, especially over extended periods. Conversely, a reel that is too small may struggle with heavier lines and demand more force when retrieving line. Look for a reel that is comfortable and well-balanced for your specific needs and preferences.

How should I store my fly fishing reel when not in use?

Proper storage is essential to protect your fly fishing reel and maintain its performance. First, clean the reel to remove any dirt, sand, or debris, and apply a lubricant to the moving parts. Then, disassemble the reel if possible, allowing for better protection against damage. Store the reel in a protective case or cover to shield it from dust, moisture, and accidental damage.

Additionally, avoid storing the reel in extreme temperatures or humidity levels, as this can lead to corrosion or warping of the materials. Ideally, keep the reel in a cool, dry area where it can remain protected and out of direct sunlight. By taking these storage precautions, you can help ensure that your fly fishing reel remains in top condition for your next adventure on the water.

As an Amazon Affiliate™ we receive compensation through qualifying purchases at no cost to you.