The Best 19 Sephora Lipsticks: Matte, Shimmer, and Everything in Between

Sephora's lipstick collection is known for its high-quality formulas and trendy shades. Our roundup compares the brand's most popular lipsticks, focusing on factors like color accuracy, longevity, and comfort.

As an Amazon Affiliate, I receive compensation from qualified purchases!

Reviews

Sephora Collection Holiday Kisses #Lipstories Lipstick

The Sephora Collection Holiday Kisses lipstick gives you that perfectly polished look with just one swipe. Whether you prefer a matte finish that tames any lip shape or a satin sheen that adds a subtle glow, there's a texture for every mood. The pigmentation is stellar—just a single coat delivers rich color that lasts all day without feeling heavy or stiff.

Sephora Collection Soft Matte Liquid Lipstick

This liquid lipstick delivers medium to high matte coverage with a smooth, comfortable feel that lasts all day. The buildable formula makes it versatile for various looks, and it works well on both lips and cheeks. The color payoff is intense with just one swipe of the comfortable, precise applicator.

Sephora Collection Hydrating Satin Lipstick

These vegan lipsticks deliver medium coverage with a satin finish, featuring natural rosehip oil and shea butter to hydrate and nourish your lips. The formula builds beautifully and provides up to 10 hours of long-lasting hydration, making them a cruelty-free alternative to traditional matte lipsticks. They come in a recyclable paper tube and are available in a range of neutral and colorful shades that look stunning with any skin tone.

Sephora Collection Cream Lip Stain Set

This four-shade set of Cream Lip Stains combines sleek simplicity with lasting color. Each matte formula, enriched with avocado oil, applies smoothly and feels surprisingly comfortable on the lips - a marked improvement over many liquid lipsticks that leave my lips feeling dry and tight. While the prices might be higher than drugstore options, the rich color payoff and long-wearing formula make it worth the investment. The lightweight, long-lasting shades transition beautifully from day to night, ideal for both casual and special occasions.

Sephora Collection #Lipstores Destination Lipstick

These limited-edition lipsticks offer rich pigmentation with an ultra-glide-on texture, featuring eight iconic shades that originally retailed at higher prices. Inspired by U. S. and Canadian destinations, each lipstick delivers lasting color with a hydrating finish. The sleek packaging makes them a pleasure to use daily, though some may prefer to use a lip liner for extended wear.

Sephora Collection Cream Lip Stain 03 Strawberry Kissed

A long-wearing cream lip stain that transforms into a velvety finish, this color offers high coverage with a comfortable, non-drying formula that moisturizes with avocado oil. The bold shade pairs beautifully with medium-toned skin, providing lasting color without the need for touch-ups throughout the day.

Sephora Favorites Holiday Lip Set

This curated collection brings together a full-size Charlotte Tilbury lipstick with Rare Beauty's hydrating balm, plus mini versions from PAT MCGRATH LABS, Too Faced, and more. The assortment includes everything from nude pinks to rich reds, with finishes ranging from matte to gloss.

Sephora Collection 96 Scorpio Lipstories

Each shade in the Sephora Collection #LIPSTORIES Astrology Lipstick range captures the essence of its Zodiac sign, from bold Scorpio red to the refined Popsicle Lips shade. The high-pigment formula delivers lasting color with just one application, though users may need to touch up throughout the day. Packaging ranges from elegant metal finishes to sleek matte designs, all featuring the brand's signature premium vegan construction.

Glossier Ultralip High Shine Lipstick

The Glossier Ultralip combines a comfortable wear with a natural satin finish, thanks to its blend of hyaluronic acid and nourishing oils. This lightweight formula builds color beautifully without feeling heavy on the lips, making it a versatile option for both everyday wear and special occasions. With its hydrating properties and buildable shade options, it's no wonder this lip product has earned high praise from users who appreciate its comfortable wear and natural look.

Glossier Generation G Sheer Matte Lipstick

This reformulated matte lipstick glides on smoothly while locking in moisture with its blue agave ingredient, though it requires a bit of warmth to activate the formula and show its best color payoff. The fan-favorite shade Like provides a natural-looking tint that builds beautifully without looking heavy or artificial. While some users have noted the drying nature of the formula, many appreciate its comfortable wear and the way it enhances their natural lip color.

Sephora Collection Love Letter Rouge Lipstick

These long-lasting lipsticks deliver intense color with a super-shiny finish. Thanks to shea and mango butters, your lips stay moisturized without feeling greasy. While some shades may stain, the hydrating formula helps prevent dryness, making them a popular choice despite minor drawbacks.

Sephora Collection Candy Love Lip Stain

This long-wearing lip stain delivers intense color with avelon-soft texture, while vitamin E nourishes and protects your lips from drying. The smooth gliding formula applies like a dream, creating a naturally matte finish that lasts for hours without feeling heavy or sticky. The lightweight sensation makes it perfect for everyday wear, whether you're running errands or attending a special event.

Sephora Collection Lipstick Room Service

These lipsticks offer a blend of satin, matte, and metallic finishes in richly pigmented formulas that cover in just one swipe. The lightweight, cream-like texture keeps your lips comfortable all day without drying them out. Each color comes in a unique packaging that adds a fun element to your makeup collection.

Glossier G Suit Drive Soft Touch Lip Creme

These lip creams deliver rich color without the drying sensation, thanks to a luxurious emollient oil blend that keeps lips soft and supple. The creamy formula applies smoothly with a precision tip that makes lining easy, though a light hand is needed for even coverage. Available in nine shades ranging from natural pinks to bold fuchsias, G Suit lets you achieve both blurred lip looks and clean lines, with wear lasting around an hour before touch-ups are needed.

Glossier Ultralip High Shine Lipstick

This hydrating lipstick delivers a natural, kissable finish while providing lasting moisture. The blend of hyaluronic acid and natural oils creates a comfortable wear that prevents drying, though users note the formula works best after lip exfoliation. With buildable color and sheer intensity, it offers both matte and glossy options across multiple shades, from soft nudes to bold reds. The lightweight balm-like texture makes touch-ups simple, though some may find the cap design prone to falling off.

Glossier Ultralip High Shine Lipstick (Trench)

This high-shine lipstick combines the comfort of a balm with the color intensity of a lip tint, enriched with hyaluronic acid to hydrate and jojoba seed oil to soften lips. The lightweight formula creates a natural, kissable finish that builds color with each swipe, perfect for both casual wear and special occasions. While the cap is notorious for falling off, users praise its moisturizing benefits and buildable shade options, with popular colors like Ember and Fete delivering just the right amount of intensity.

Freck Beauty Makeout Club Soft Blur Lipstick

The Freck Beauty Makeout Club Soft Blur Lipstick combines royal orchid extract protection with magnolia bark antioxidants for conditioned lips. Its vegan lanolin substitute creates a smooth, matte finish that's neither drying nor heavy, making it a versatile addition to any makeup routine. Users particularly appreciate its buildable formula and natural-looking results, though the orange-leaning color tends to be more nude-toned in person than promised by swatches.

Saie Lip Blur Soft Matte Hydrating Lipstick

This matte lipstick strikes the perfect balance of intense pigmentation and natural moisture, thanks to its hydrating formula that includes olive oil and berry fruit wax. The soft-focus effect creates beautifully blurred lip edges while the long-wearing formula keeps lips smooth and supple all day. The comfortable, buildable coverage lets you achieve everything from natural nudes to bold reds without the usual compromises of matte lipsticks.

Glossier | Ultralip | Villa | Hydrating Lipstick

Hydrating lip balm meets long-wearing lipstick in Glossier's popular Ultralip formula. Infused with hyaluronic acid, the smooth, buildable lipstick provides intense moisture while creating a high-shine finish that lasts all day. The comfortable wear pairs balmy texture with precise application, though some users find the cap design could be more secure.

Buyer's Guide

Sephora lipsticks offer a variety of finishes and shades, from matte to gloss. When selecting a lipstick, consider factors like color intensity, formula type, and long-lasting power.

Color Options

Sephora's lipstick palette offers a wide range of colors, from neutral shades to bold options. Common trends include nudes, reds, and berry tones. Consider your undertone (cool or warm) when choosing a shade to ensure the lipstick appears true to color.

Formula Types

Sephora lipsticks come in several formula options, including matte, cream, and gloss finishes. Matte lipsticks are long-lasting and ideal for formal occasions, while cream formulations glide on smoothly and feel more hydrating. Gloss options provide high shine and are suitable for daytime wear.

Long-Lasting Power

Long-lasting lipsticks resist feathering and smudging throughout the day. Look for products containing ingredients like iron oxides and silicones, which help lock color in place. Testing the lipstick's formula on a swatch and checking for water resistance can also indicate its staying power.

Skin Compatibility

Sephora lipsticks vary in their formula properties, which can affect skin comfort. Formulae with more oils and emollients tend to feel more hydrating, while matte finishes may be drier. Those with sensitive skin should look for products with minimal ingredients and fragrance-free options to avoid irritation.

FAQ

What sets Sephora lipstick apart from other makeup brands?

Sephora lipstick combines high-quality pigmentation with a wide range of formulas to suit every skin type and preference. Their lipsticks are known for their smooth texture and staying power, while offering comfortable wear throughout the day.

Unlike some drugstore brands, Sephora lipsticks contain nourishing ingredients that help moisturize the lips, making them suitable for daily use without drying out the lip tissue.

How many different lipsticks does Sephora carry?

Sephora's lipstick collection includes over 1,000 shades across various lines. The brand constantly updates its inventory, so this number changes regularly. Their expansive shade selection makes it easy to find multiple shades that match different skin tones and preferences.

While the exact number may fluctuate, you can expect to find at least 500 distinct shades across Sephora's top-selling lipstick lines, including their main collection and luxury brands like Ysl and Stila.

What are the main types of lipstick formulas available at Sephora?

Sephora offers several key lipstick formulas to cater to different needs and preferences. Their main options include matte, gloss, cream, and liquid formulas, each with distinct properties for lasting color and feel on the lips.

Matte lipsticks provide intense color with moderate dryness, glosses offer high shine with little to no color, cream formulas blend pigment with moisture, and liquid lipsticks deliver intense payoff in a convenient, brush-applied format.

Can Sephora lipsticks be customized?

Yes, Sephora offers customizable lipstick options through their My Color IQ personalization service. This allows customers to select their ideal color match based on their skin tone and preferences.

Additionally, Sephora's Cream Lip Color formula can be mixed with their Lip Tints to create personalized shades, and their Lip Liner Pencils can be used to define and enhance any lipstick application.

Are Sephora lipsticks cruelty-free?

While Sephora sources from both cruelty-free and non-cruelty-free brands, their own products and many of their partnerships are cruelty-free. The brand clearly labels these products on their website.

However, it's important to note that not all Sephora-branded lipsticks are cruelty-free. Always check the specific product page for cruelty-free certifications if this is a priority for you.

How should I choose the right Sephora lipstick formula?

Selecting the right formula depends on your preference between shine and coverage. Matte formulas are best for everyday wear with lasting color, while glosses work well for special occasions or as a highlighter.

Consider your skin type and personal comfort level with different finishes. Dry skin may prefer the moisture-locking properties of cream formulas, while oilier skin might benefit from the long-wearing quality of matte lipsticks.

As an Amazon Affiliate, I receive compensation from qualified purchases!