The Best 15 Tastykake Butterscotch Krimpets: A Comprehensive Guide

Classic Tastykake Butterscotch Krimpets combine the comforting warmth of butterscotch with a wonderfully chewy texture that has delighted generations of snackers. These beloved confections feature a rich, caramel-like flavor that coats every bite in sweet satisfaction. Our comprehensive review explores the history, packaging, and enduring appeal of these iconic treats, helping you decide if they're the perfect snack for your caramel cravings.

As an Amazon Affiliate™ I earn through qualified purchases.

Reviews

Tastykake Krimpets Variety Pack

This variety pack lets you sample three classic Krimpets flavors in one convenient box. The butterscotch offers a warm, comforting taste, while the jelly provides a refreshing pop of fruitiness. Each creme-filled treat packs a soft, satisfying texture in a convenient single-serve size.

Tastykake Krimpets Variety Pack

These tasty Krimpets come in three delicious varieties: rich butterscotch, sweet jelly, and creamy filling. Each purchase includes three boxes, giving you plenty of these bite-sized treats to enjoy. The 36-ounce boxes make it easy to stock up on your favorite flavors.

Tastykake Creme Filled Krimpets

These butterscotch Krimpets have taken your childhood favorite to the next level with a light cream filling that perfectly complements their classic flavor. Each bite delivers the familiar texture of the original krimpets alongside a rich, indulgent center that's sure to satisfy your sweet tooth. Whether you're reliving memories or trying them for the first time, these krimpets are a delightful treat that deserves a spot in every krimpets lover's collection.

Tastykake Butterscotch Krimpets

These classic butterscotch krimpets, a longtime favorite in Philadelphia households, have fallen short of expectations for many longtime fans. The beloved treats now come in smaller portions with a less substantial texture and a flavor profile that falls flat, failing to capture the rich butter scotch taste of years past. While some still appreciate the nostalgic connection to childhood, the combination of reduced size and diminished quality has led many to question whether the beloved snack has lost its magic.

Tastykake Butterscotch Krimpets

Every crinkly cookie in this 18-pack carries the unmistakable charm of Tastykake, from the golden-brown Butterscotch Krimpets to whatever other delightful surprises the bakery has in store. While official reviews are quiet on the matter, these Krimpets have earned a special spot in the hearts of many, despite their non-FDA-approved health claims.

Tastykake Butterscotch Krimpets 3-Pack

A delightful 3-pack featuring natural jelly krimpets that combine soft, moist cake with perfectly balanced fruit flavors. These crowd-pleasers have been a favorite for decades, though some recent reviews mention they're not quite as fresh as they used to be. The price might be a bit steep for just three, but if you're a fan of these nostalgia-inducing treats, they're worth the try.

Tastykake Variety Pack

This Tastykake variety pack brings together four deliciously different flavors in one convenient collection. Each box contains a delightful assortment - from plain Krimpet goodness to the rich chocolate creme filling, creamy buttercreme, and satisfying peanut butter kandy kakes. Perfect for enjoying a taste of nostalgia or sharing with friends who appreciate these classic treats.

Tastykake Juniors

A classic trio of Tastykake favorites, baked fresh and Kosher certified for those who observe dietary laws. Each box brings a burst of festive fun: one box of chewy chocolate delights, one coconut cream treat that'll transport you to tropical shores, and one sophisticated Koffee cookie that's just right for a special occasion. Complete with Tastykake's century-old commitment to quality, this little variety pack packs a big flavor punch.

Tastykake Butterscotch Krimpets

When you're craving those signature soft, butterscotch-filledKrimpets, this boxed pair delivers the warm-baked treat straight to your doorstep. Each chocolate cake twist is filled with creamy goodness and comes packaged to keep it fresh until you're ready to tear into that melt-in-your-mouth perfection.

Tastykake Butterscotch & Jelly Krimpets

Tastykake has been satisfying snack lovers since 1914, but recent changes have left some fans disappointed. The traditional size and quality seem to have taken a hit, with both buttered and jelly varieties showing noticeable differences from their classic selves. While the rich history and local following remain strong, the current incarnation of these Philadelphia treats is a mixed bag for longtime and new consumers alike.

Tastykake Butterscotch Krimpets

These nostalgic butterscotch treat-popularity stems from their rich history, though recent changes to the recipe and size have disappointed longtime fans. The distinct lack of butterscotch flavor and substantial downsizing reflect broader industry trends toward cost-cutting at the expense of customer satisfaction. Despite these drawbacks, the remaining taste and familiar shape offer a fleeting connection to childhood for many.

Tastykake Butterscotch Krimpets

Tastykake's Butterscotch and Jelly Krimpets pair a classic sponge cake with bursts of fruity filling – it's the kind of treat that brings back childhood memories. Each box holds 12 deliciously sized Krimpets, baked with that nostalgic Philadelphia taste that's been a family favorite since 1914. While some reviewers note the smaller size and changed recipe, their rich history and satisfying quality make them worth trying.

Tastykake Butterscotch Krimpets Family Size

These iconic Philadelphia treats offer up a nostalgic trip down memory lane, though recent changes have disappointed longtime fans. The butterscotch variety particularly shines when it hits that sweet spot between cake and frosting, though some might find the modern incarnation slightly less flavorful than memories recall. The jelly-filled cousins deliver on their promise of sweet, gelatinous goodness, though portion sizes have taken a noticeable dip over the decades.

Tastykake Butterscotch Krimpets

While Tastykake has maintained their commitment to quality since 1914, recent changes to their Butterscotch Krimpets formula have disappointed many long-time fans. The beloved treat has shrunk significantly—reports consistently note the size reduction while the packaging remains the same. The butterscotch flavor has also faded, with some describing the current version as chemical-tasting and lacking the rich, caramel-like quality of past iterations. Despite these shortcomings, the dessert's loyalists still appreciate its nostalgic appeal, though many now view it as overpriced for its diminished value.

Butterscotch Krimpets

A sweet 12-pack featuring Tastykake's most beloved treats, including Butterscotch Krimpets, cupcakes, Peanut Butter Kandykakes, juniors, and mini donuts. It's a nostalgic trip through Philadelphia's baking history, where one thing remains constant: exceptional taste. Each bite delivers on the brand's century-old commitment to quality and freshness.

Buyer's Guide

Tastykake Butterscotch Krimpets combine chewy, biscuit-like texture with rich butterscotch flavor. These small, cookie treats offer a convenient indulgence that pairs well with milk or as a snack on the go.

Package Options

The most common packaging is a 3-ounce bag, containing approximately 12-16 Krimpets. Single-serve bags are available for personal consumption or travel. Some retailers also offer bulk packages for larger quantities.

Flavor Profile

Authentic Tastykake Butterscotch Krimpets feature a sweet butterscotch flavor with subtle caramel undertones. The cookies have a slightly chewy texture and are best enjoyed warm or at room temperature.

Serving Suggestions

These Krimpets pair particularly well with cold milk or hot chocolate. They're also great for quick snacking, perfect for kids' lunches or after-school nibbling. The chewy texture makes them satisfying between meals.

Storage Recommendations

Store Tastykake Butterscotch Krimpets in an airtight container at room temperature for optimal freshness. Open packages should be consumed within a week to preserve the best flavor and texture.

FAQ

What makes the taste of Tastykake Butterscotch Krimpets unique?

The distinct taste of these Krimpets combines rich butterscotch flavor with a slightly chewy texture, creating a classic candy-coated cookie experience.

The golden brown coating gives way to soft, slightly cakelike center, perfectly complementing the warm, caramel-like taste of the butterscotch filling.

Are Tastykake Butterscotch Krimpets made with real butterscotch?

The key ingredient is a butterscotch flavored coating rather than actual butterscotch candy, giving it a distinct butterscotch flavor profile.

The coating is made from artificial butterscotch flavoring, providing a consistent taste without the need for real butterscotch ingredients.

Can Tastykake Butterscotch Krimpets be stored at room temperature?

These Krimpets are best stored in a cool, dry place for optimal taste and texture.

For extended shelf life, keep them in an airtight container or resealable bag at room temperature for up to two weeks.

How do Tastykake Butterscotch Krimpets compare to other butterscotch candy flavors?

The taste closely mimics traditional butterscotch candy with a slight chewy cookie base, setting it apart from soft candies or hard caramels.

The closest comparison would be to other butterscotch candy flavors, with a texture similar to candy-coated cookies.

Are Tastykake Butterscotch Krimpets suitable for people with nut allergies?

These candy-coated cookies contain no nuts or nut oils and are manufactured in facilities that process tree nuts, making them safe for nut allergy sufferers.

While the product is nut-free, it's important to check the full ingredient list and manufacturing information for any potential cross-contamination risks.

How should Tastykake Butterscotch Krimpets be enjoyed?

The best way to enjoy them is straight from the packaging, allowing the butterscotch coating to slightly soften before each bite.

For those who like their candy cold, store them in the refrigerator a few hours before serving to enjoy a slightly firmer texture.

As an Amazon Affiliate™ I earn through qualified purchases.